I have been thinking for a long time about our choices. I saw a play today, the Women of Lockerbie. It really was all about death and grief and healing. Yeah, not your fun tap dancing musical. We all cried all our makeup off.
In it, there is a dialogue the women have about choices.
They say that our every day is made up of so many tiny choices, each with a consequence.
“You choose Delta, your son lives. You choose Panam, your son dies.
You walk your dog a few minutes earlier then you usually do and you miss your living room getting crushed by a plane.
You walk out the door in the rain, and you meet your future husband.
Sometimes I wonder if it is us who makes these choices at all, or if it’s something bigger, like God.”
Of course, they say it better, and with Scottish accents. But it really made me think and decide to finally turn that pondering into words here.
I think it’s a question so many people wonder about. Do we have any control? Or is it all God?
What if we had made different choices?
What if I hand’t let him go on that hunting trip? What if they came home when they’d planned instead of staying the extra night? What if I had thrown a fit and made him come home when he told me that he was staying longer? What if I didn’t let him buy that stupid plane in the first place? What if . . .
Was it Brad’s choices, my choices, someone else’s choices, that lead to his death, or has it always been Heavenly Father’s plan for him to die then?
When Brad was sent from Heaven to Earth did Heavenly Father tell him, “Okay Brad, you’re going to live for 28 years, then I’m going to have you die in a plane crash, leaving your wife and daughter alone.”
That just doesn’t seem right.
I don’t think God would take his precious son or daughter and tell them, “You’re going to come down into the world, and I’m going to have you get addicted to drugs, and then I’ll have you overdose and die.”
I just don’t think that Heavenly Father works like that. I don’t think that he sits up in Heaven, like an almighty puppet master, just pulling the strings, not allowing us any control in our lives.
But I also don’t think that he just sits back and lets us have at it with no intervention at all. What a mess that would be.
We have our agency. That’s the whole point, right? We have the right to choose. We can choose to get in the car, or ride the bus. They’ll both have consequences. We can choose to follow God’s commandments, or disregard them completely. They’ll both have consequences.
So, at what point does Heavenly Father intervene? Would he jump in and totally stop us if he doesn’t like the choices we’re making? If that’s not his plan?
I know we’ve all heard of the stories when someone gets in an awful car crash and should be dead, but by some miracle they are alive. Did He intervene then because it wasn’t their time? Or would he have sat back and said, “you used your agency to choose to go down that road, this are the consequence.”
I just don’t know.
This I do know.
I know that Heavenly Father KNEW that this was going to happen to Brad. I don’t know if it was his plan all along, or if could see where Brad’s choices were leading. I can see the ways that he did intervene, though at the time, I didn’t understand it.
Brad and I were supposed to be building a house. We started planning this house, this dream, only two months after we met. If you knew Brad, you know that once he gets excited about something he obsesses until he has it exactly the way he wants.
Though he was really excited, for some reason, Brad kept stalling when it came to our house. It was so strange to me. I was usually the one pulling back on the reigns, and he was the one running head first, no second thoughts. After weeks, or even months, I pushed him to tell me why he was stalling. He said that every time he went to do something serious about selling our house or building a new one, he just didn’t feel quite right about it, though he never could pinpoint why. I don’t even think he recognized that the Spirit was trying to tell him something until we talked it out. So we decided to hold off, work on some projects at this house and continue to pray about it.
In hindsight, I am so grateful for that. If Brad had ignored his feelings, or if he had chose not to act on them, right now, I would probably be living in a rented apartment, building a way too big/expensive house that I wound’t want to live in. I’m so grateful that Heavenly Father intervened. But it was still our choice to listen.
I think that’s how it works most of the time.
We have to choose if we are going to let Heavenly Father direct and guide our lives.
I can see other ways that he guided others live's and protected them.
Many still marvel that Brad was alone on that fateful flight. So many feel shaken because they feel like they should have been in the back seat with Brad, but for some reason, they weren’t.
One of Brad’s buddies even asked to get in the plane on that last take off, but Brad said no. He felt uncomfortable about the length of the runway and didn’t want to push it with two people. Was that Brad just being overly cautious or did he feel prompted to not let him in the plane?
Did he feel a prompting about flying right then and choose not to listen? I have no idea. The thought haunts me.
I do know that God can intervene if he wants. Most of the time it’s our choice to allow it. Could God have warned Brad, or me or his friends and kept Brad from harm? Yes. Did he and we just didn’t listen? Maybe. I hope not.
If it really wasn’t Brad’s time, could he have intervened, even though Brad’s agency led him there? Yes. I know he could’ve. He could have changed that one stupid draft that wasn’t there just two minutes before. He could’ve broken the plane. He could’ve made it rain. But he didn’t. Which tells me that though God doesn’t pull the puppet strings and we still make our own choices, this was his will.
It was not his will for someone else to get in the back seat with Brad. Heavenly Father intervened. And Brad chose to listen.
There are so many things that happened around this time of Brad’s death, too many things to ignore and say that Heavenly Father doesn’t have a hand in my life. Heavenly Father did so many things to prepare us all for this.
Like Brad’s sister having a random day off work and spending almost all of it at with Brad at the cabin.
Like Brad’s Dad, who suddenly decided to take the whole family to Disneyland even though he swore that he wouldn't take Leah until she was five. We all went on a family vacation just two weeks before Brad died. We got our last family picture.
Like Brad’s good friend who was back home for just a few days and made a sudden decision to stop by and see Brad before he had to leave again. Brad was the last person he saw here at home. He didn’t even see his Dad.
There are just too many things to make me believe that Heavenly Father really does have a hand in my life. And he always will, if I will allow it and be open to it.
Though I don’t fully understand it and I straight up don’t like it, I know that Heavenly Father was in control on that day. It was his will for this to happen–for Brad to go home, and for me, and my family to have this trial in our lives.
I don’t know if any of this makes sense. It’s mostly just me hammering out my thoughts, trying to make sense of it while I go. It all sounded much more concise and powerful when I was laying on the couch with a migraine.
What do you guys think about it? Any insights? Any thoughts to help me figure this one out?
Tricky life questions.